MintMint

Airlines seek legal clarity on costs, liability, supply gaps in draft green fuel policy

4 min de lecture

New Delhi, Nov. 17 -- The government's push to get airlines flying on greener fuel is prompting carriers to seek legal clarity on the proposed sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) mandate for international flights, particularly on steep fuel premiums, compliance rules, penalties, and who would be liable if supplies fall short.

The draft National Policy on Sustainable Aviation Fuel, released on 5 November, proposes SAF blending of 1% in 2027, 2% in 2028, 3% in 2029 and 5% in 2030 for international flights departing from India.

It also proposes that scheduled international airlines source or uplift at least 90% of their annual fuel requirement from international airports in India, a move aimed at preventing fuel tankering and creating demand for fuel supplied domestically.

Fuel tankering is the aviation practice where an aircraft carries more fuel than is required for its outbound flight so that it can avoid or reduce refuelling at its destination airport. Because ATF in India is heavily taxed (via state VAT and excise duties), it is often more expensive than at major overseas hubs like Dubai, Doha, or Singapore. Foreign carriers flying into India frequently "tanker" cheaper fuel from abroad-carrying enough extra fuel on the inbound flight so they need to buy very little in India for the return leg.

The draft policy also proposes a Rs.500 crore innovation seed fund to support domestic SAF production, new technologies and pilot projects.

SAF can be made from agricultural waste and used cooking oil. Depending on the production pathway, it can reduce lifecycle emissions compared with conventional jet fuel and can be used in existing aircraft as a "drop-in" fuel, subject to applicable standards.

The proposals have prompted airlines to seek legal advice on how the obligations would work and how they could affect existing fuel-supply contracts.

The financial stakes are high. According to Jainam Shah, aviation analyst at Equirus Securities, a 5% SAF blend would require around 290 million litres of SAF a year by 2030. Assuming conventional ATF costs Rs.85-90 a litre and SAF carries a 50-200% premium, the additional annual procurement cost could reach Rs.1,200-5,200 crore, he said. India currently has 106,500 tonnes (around 133 million litres) of annual SAF co-processing capacity across four certified refinery facilities, according to a September 2026 report by S&P Global and the SAF Association.

Industry watchers estimate the mandate could lift overall airline fuel bills by 2-3% as blending targets rise, squeezing carrier margins, particularly if airlines cannot pass the extra cost on through higher fares. IndiGo, India's largest airline, reported a net loss of Rs.1,879.1 crore in the September quarter as its fuel bill surged 67.2% to Rs.9,966.8 crore.

Legal experts said the cost burden is compounded by how little control airlines have over pricing and procurement. "For airlines, the primary concern is the additional financial and operational burden arising from the proposed mandate. SAF is currently estimated to cost approximately two to three times as much as conventional aviation turbine fuel," said Prashanth Sabeshan, partner at Dentons Link Legal, adding that the strain will deepen as the mandate climbs to 5% by 2030.

"Airlines are not objecting to SAF or to a 1% start. The questions are practical. SAF costs two to three times ATF, the airline has no say over who supplies it or at what price, and the penalty amounts are not yet known," said Ankita Kumar, partner at Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas. "Currently the draft is at the consultation stage so our advice is around policy conversations with regulators and not implementation," she added.

Beyond higher fuel bills, legal experts warned that the draft policy leaves crucial enforcement and liability questions unanswered. Poonam Verma Sengupta, partner at JSA Advocates & Solicitors, said three key legal issues need to be addressed before the mandate can be implemented. "In our view, three key legal bottlenecks need to be addressed for the mandate to be implemented effectively: the absence of a statutory basis for the blending mandate; gaps in the compliance framework; and the absence of a mechanism for sharing the SAF cost premium," she said.

For law firms, the central issue is who should bear responsibility when an airline cannot obtain enough SAF. The draft places key obligations on airlines even though they have no control over physical blending and supply at airports, which are handled by fuel suppliers and oil marketing companies.

Lawyers said the biggest concern would arise if an airline is willing to comply but SAF is simply unavailable. "Airlines are concerned about potential penalisation for supply shortfalls they cannot control, given that obligatory provisions seem concentrated upon the airlines, and do not affect the production pipeline," said Neelakantan VR, partner at Khaitan & Co.

Neelakantan suggested a hybrid approach under which suppliers would be responsible for blending SAF, airlines would handle fuel uplift and reporting, and a registry would track the environmental benefits. Such an approach could reduce disputes over who should bear penalties or losses arising from SAF shortages.

The policy is also linked to a wider global effort to cut aviation emissions. Under the Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (CORSIA), airlines monitor emissions from international flights and can use qualifying SAF as one of the measures to reduce their offsetting requirements. India is a signatory, which makes implementation of blended aviation fuel mandatory from January 2027.

"The government should consult aircraft manufacturers such as Boeing and Airbus to confirm that the proposed SAF blend is compatible with their aircraft. This exercise is yet to be completed," said Mark Martin, founder and CEO of Martin Consulting.

Law firms also expect airlines to review their long-term fuel contracts. Many existing agreements were written before SAF became part of India's aviation policy and may not clearly address SAF pricing, sustainability certificates, environmental benefits or penalties.

"SAF supply agreements will need to clearly address supply shortfalls, alternative procurement, pricing and the allocation of additional costs. Where supplies fall short, these provisions could become critical in determining the parties' rights and liabilities," said Sengupta of JSA.

Queries emailed to Air India, IndiGo, Indian Oil, Hindustan Petroleum Limited, and the ministries of civil aviation and petroleum remained unanswered at the time of publishing.

Clause de non-responsabilité

Lire l'article complet
Obtenez un accès illimité aux articles de Mint et à toutes les autres sources d'actualités sur TradingView.